On Wednesday night, Big Pauly's Pizza in Plainfield, New Jersey, was vandalized for the second time in less than two years. The owner, Paul Horwath, received a call from his security provider about 11 p.m. from his home informing him of the incident. The suspect was wearing a mask and gloves, tearing out a cash register and a secondary one used as a punch clock for employees. The incident left four of the restaurant's eight front windows shattered. The first incident occurred on Jan. 31, 2025, and police have not yet identified an offender.